Cast
Joshua ZemanHimself
Barbara BrancaccioHerself
Bill EllisHimself - Professor of Folklore, Penn State- Dorothy D'ElettoHerself - Archivist & Researcher
Geraldo RiveraHimself - Reporter (archive footage)- Karen SchweigerHerself - Jennifer Schweiger's Mother
- David NavarroHimself - Former Newscaster
- Donna CutugnoHerself - Founder, Friends of Jennifer
- Ralph AquinoHimself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Bobby JensenHimself - Retired Detective, NYPD
- Ernie AnastosHimself - Reporter (archive footage)
- Andre RandHimself - Suspect
- Jim CallaghanHimself - Former Editor, Staten Island Eagle
- Jim DolanHimself - Reporter (archive footage)
- Theresa DoyleHerself - Searcher for Jennifer
